By offering digital payment methods like PayPal, Venmo, Apple Pay, and Google Pay, nonprofits can increase conversion rates while providing a secure, quick giving experience. In this article, we dive into the benefits of offering payment through digital wallets and how Neon Pay offers a simple way to accept donors’ favorite payment methods. If you want to remove friction and build a high-conversion donor experience, this one’s for you.
For fundraisers, optimizing the speed with which donors turn their intent to give into a completed gift is surprisingly critical. Speed matters! Any friction, hiccup, or reason to leave the process—like hunting for a credit card or filling out a long form—is a reason for donors to walk away.
When you only have moments to convert intent into actual support, digital wallets for nonprofits and their seamless payment technology can be transformative.
Credit cards are still the most popular form of online giving (63% of donors prefer this method). Still, 10% of donors prefer PayPal, and there is a smaller set of donors who prefer using digital wallets like Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Venmo to support their favorite organizations.
This can have big implications. When they deliver a speedy donation process and honor donors’ preference for digital wallets, nonprofits can grow 12.7% faster than organizations that do not offer digital payments.
Digital wallets are no longer just a “nice to have.” In this article, we’ll cover how digital wallets can help you reach new audiences, key payment options to consider, how to capitalize on digital wallets, and how the right nonprofit payment processor will include these payment options.
Reaching New Audiences with Digital Wallets
In order to grow your donor base, you need to meet people where they already are. Digital natives—specifically Millennials, Gen Z, and even Gen Alpha (!)—use digital wallets for both convenience and because they’re a trusted, familiar form of payment that these folks are using regularly, if not every day.
From a fundraiser’s perspective, digital wallets are also a superstar because they ease the donation process. With faster, one-click mobile checkout, digital wallets reduce manual data entry, reduce form abandonment, and ultimately increase conversion rates.
Let’s dive into four key platforms.
An Overview of Digital Wallet Options
| Payment Method | Audience | Key Benefits |
|---|---|---|
| PayPal | Appeals to all ages, including Gen X and Baby Boomers. | High donor confidence, high conversion rates, and a global reach. |
| Venmo | Heavy lean toward Gen Z, Millennials, and even Gen Alpha (!!) who love the social aspect of the platform. | Mobile-first giving, a familiar and trusted platform, and QR capabilities. |
| Apple Pay | Most popular with Gen Z and can be used by any donor with an iPhone. | Eliminates forms, reduces donor drop off, and offers contactless in-person payment options. |
| Google Pay | Most popular with Gen Z and perfect for donors on Android or Chrome. | Universally accessible, fast and secure, and browser-level convenience. |
PayPal
PayPal is often the first digital wallet nonprofits adopt because of its massive existing user base. With 432 million users worldwide and 278.1 million accounts in the U.S., it’s the leading e-commerce payment processor.
While digital payments tend to skew to a younger audience, Gen X and Baby Boomers often choose PayPal because they are highly concerned about privacy and security, and they trust the established brand for transactions.
Key Benefits of PayPal
- Donor Confidence: Donors feel secure because they don’t have to share raw credit card details with a new site.
- High Conversion: According to research by Nielsen Media commissioned by PayPal in 2022, PayPal users are nearly four times as likely to donate when PayPal is an option. Additionally, the research found that PayPal as a payment option on your online donation forms can dramatically increase unplanned gifts (by 32%) and repeat donations (by 79%).
- Global Reach: PayPal can be extremely useful for organizations with international supporters as it easily handles multiple currencies.
Venmo
Venmo is the go-to for Millennial, Gen Z, and Gen Alpha (!!!) supporters, who prioritize speed and social accessibility. It has more than 83 million users, with its largest user age group being 25-34 year-olds.
Key Benefits of Venmo
- Mobile-First Giving: It is optimized for one-tap checkouts and perfect for social media campaigns or mobile donation pages.
- Daily Integration: Over 38% of Americans use Venmo for transactions, making a donation feel like an already familiar process.
- QR Capability: Venmo’s native QR code support makes it the premier choice for collecting donations at live events like galas or community walks.
Apple Pay
Apple Pay turns an iPhone or Mac into a one-click giving tool. It has about 624 million users worldwide, including a projected 22.3% of American consumers aged 14 and up.
Key Benefits of Apple Pay
- Shorten Forms: Donors don’t need to type in their name, address, or card number. Apple Pay securely passes this info to your processor.
- Reduced Drop-off: By removing the need to dig for a card, you can help prevent drop-off rates that are often seen at the payment info stage.
- Contactless In-Person Payments: It is perfect for on-site “Tap to Pay” fundraising at physical locations.
Google Pay
Google Pay provides a high-speed, secure donation option for Android users. With 820 million active users worldwide, 49% of U.S. users choose Google Pay for tap-to-pay transactions.
Key Benefits of Google Pay
- Universal Accessibility: It appears dynamically based on the donor’s device, which ensures that every mobile user sees a familiar, trusted button.
- Fast & Secure: It uses tokens to protect financial data, giving donors peace of mind that their information is never exposed.
- Browser-Level Convenience: For donors giving from their desktop, Google Pay can pull saved information directly from their Google account. This keeps the checkout process fast and secure.
Do You Know Your Donors?
They’re more generous than you might think … and we have proof. Download The Generosity Report today!
5 Opportunities to Capitalize on Digital Wallets for Nonprofits
So, we’ve established how digital wallets can reach new audiences and have key features that appeal to donors. Now, let’s dive into how digital wallets can unlock better, more efficient ways for nonprofits to receive donations and manage donor relationships.
Here’s a rundown of five example use cases of how and why to use digital wallets to up your fundraising game.
1. Galas and Live Events
Digital payment methods can help you maximize revenue at events or galas. Use QR codes placed strategically around your event on table tents or large screens, and allow attendees to scan a code and give in seconds. It’s quick, seamless, and allows donors to give without missing key moments in your program. This digital giving option removes any clutter of paper pledge cards and prevents the need to scramble for a pen when the auctioneer is speaking.
2. Next-Gen Campaigns
Attract younger supporters (aka your future generation of donors) by leading with Venmo (or other digital giving options) for your social media campaigns. Millennials and Gen Z often treat their Venmo balance like “fun money,” which makes them more likely to make a spontaneous gift if they don’t have to leave the app. You’re meeting these donors exactly where they already are, which makes giving easy and convenient.
3. Reducing Donation Form Abandonment
Digital wallets’ use of one-tap checkout helps to capture the majority of people who typically drop off when they have to dig out a physical credit card. When a donor sees the Apple Pay or Google Pay button, they know they can finish the process with a simple thumbprint or face scan. This eliminates the friction of manual data entry, ensuring that a donor’s good intention actually turns into a completed gift.
4. Recurring Giving Growth
Because many people already use PayPal for their monthly streaming services or utility bills, adding a monthly gift to your nonprofit feels like a natural extension of their budget. As we noted above, offering PayPal as a payment option on your online donation forms can dramatically increase repeat donations by as much as 79%. Plus, people already trust the platform, which can lead to higher retention rates as donors feel in control of their giving through a platform they navigate every day.
5. Simplified Data Reconciliation for Your Team
A good nonprofit CRM (like Neon CRM) will allow your team to see Apple Pay, Google Pay, Venmo, and PayPal gifts alongside your traditional credit card transactions, all in one place. This saves your finance person hours of manual export work and ensures your donor records stay clean and actionable. (More on that coming next!)
Elevate Your Digital Giving Experience with Neon Pay
At Neon One, our goal is to help you raise more and make the giving experience seamless for your supporters. We’ve removed the barriers to entry by integrating native digital wallet payments, including PayPal, Venmo, Apple Pay, and Google Pay, directly into Neon Pay.
Ready to modernize your fundraising?
Digital Wallet FAQs
No, there are generally no additional platform fees for accepting digital wallet transactions. In Neon Pay, transactions made via PayPal and Venmo are processed at our standard processing rate. A major advantage of using Neon Pay is that you can enable donor-covered fees.
One of the biggest pain points for nonprofits is having donations scattered across separate PayPal or Venmo accounts. Neon Pay solves this by consolidating all gifts into a single, consistent user interface. All PayPal and Venmo transactions flow directly into your Neon CRM, ensuring your donor records and financial reports are accurate without the need for manual data entry.
Yes, digital wallets are often more secure than traditional credit card entries. They provide a “vaulted” experience, meaning the donor’s raw credit card details are never exposed to your website. Additionally, Neon Pay is a Level 1 PCI-compliant platform, providing top-tier security and fraud analysis to protect both your organization and your supporters.
While many standalone third-party processors struggle with recurring digital gifts, the Neon Pay integration is designed to support recurring PayPal donations. This allows your organization to maximize long-term revenue and build more sustainable donor relationships. Donors can also self-serve to update their payment information or schedules directly through the platform.
