Making decisions about new investments, especially in software like a CRM, is something nonprofit boards often approach with caution. It’s understandable—boards are tasked with ensuring the financial health of the organization and managing risks.
However, the hesitation to invest in new technology can sometimes hold a nonprofit back from reaching its full potential. If you’re facing resistance from your board on purchasing a new CRM, this guide will help you navigate and overcome common objections.
Objection #1: “It will cost too much.”
When it comes to proposing a new CRM to your nonprofit board, one of the most significant hurdles you’re likely to encounter is the issue of cost.
Nonprofit boards are often laser-focused on maintaining a tight budget, and any new expenditure is scrutinized heavily. That’s why you should reframe the conversation around the cost of a CRM from expense to investment.
Investing in a CRM isn’t just spending money! It’s a strategic investment in the future of your organization.
Here’s Why CRMs are an Investment
For one thing, a well-implemented CRM can significantly improve donor retention rates, and retaining donors is far more cost-effective than constantly acquiring new donors. A CRM allows you to segment your donors, tailor communications, and create more personalized donor journeys—all of which contribute to higher retention rates.
A powerful CRM can also automate many of the repetitive, time-consuming tasks that currently take up valuable staff time, like data entry, tracking donations, and generating reports.
By making your operations more efficient, a CRM doesn’t just save you time—it also saves you money.
A CRM can also make your fundraising activities more effective. It will provide you with the data and insights needed to identify fundraising opportunities, tailor appeals, and maximize donor engagement.
You’ll be able to track your campaigns’ success in real time, make data-driven decisions, and adjust strategies on the fly to raise more.
While you’re evaluating how much more you can raise with a CRM, it’s also important to consider the costs of not investing in a CRM. Outdated systems can lead to errors, data silos, and inconsistencies that undermine your efforts and waste precious resources.
The longer you wait to invest in a CRM, the more these inefficiencies can compound—and that will lead to greater challenges down the road.
Respond by Focusing on ROI:
To make a compelling case to your board, present a clear and tangible argument for the return on investment (ROI) that this new CRM can deliver.
Your calculation should include:
- Cost Savings: Calculate the potential savings from improved donor retention, increased staff efficiency, and reduced need for additional hires or overtime.
- Revenue Growth: Estimate the additional revenue that could be generated from more successful fundraising campaigns, higher donor retention rates, and increased average donation amounts.
- Time Savings: Quantify the amount of staff time saved by automating tasks and streamlining processes, and translate this into financial terms by considering the cost of staff time.
By presenting a CRM as a tool that pays for itself and drives growth and efficiency, you can help your board see it as a smart investment in the organization’s future.
Objection #2: “Our current CRM is good enough.”
One of the most common objections you may encounter is the belief that the tools your organization currently uses are “good enough.”
This sentiment is often rooted in a mindset of risk aversion and comfort with the status quo. The board might reason, “If it’s not broken, why fix it?”
While this perspective is understandable, it’s important to challenge it and encourage a shift from “good enough” to “as great as we can be.”
The Dangers of Techno-Complacency
When a board believes that existing tools are sufficient, it’s really important to differentiate between merely surviving and truly thriving. The tools that may have served your nonprofit well in the past could now be holding you back from reaching your full potential!
Even if your current systems aren’t causing overt problems, they could be fostering inefficiencies that hinder your nonprofit’s growth. Outdated tools often lead to a patchwork of processes that require manual intervention, increasing the risk of errors and duplicative efforts.
Another issue with maintaining outdated or disparate tools is the lack of integrations with other parts of your nonprofit’s tech stack. When your systems don’t communicate with each other, you end up with data silos—isolated pockets of information that are difficult to access and analyze holistically.
While your current tools might suffice for today’s needs, what about tomorrow’s? A CRM that meets your needs today might not be able to scale with your organization, leading to costly transitions in the future.
Investing in a robust, scalable CRM now can save your organization the time, money, and disruption of having to switch systems again in a few years.
Respond with an “Audit” of Your Current System(s)
To convince your board to move beyond the “good enough” mindset, it’s essential to provide concrete evidence of where your current systems fall short and how a new CRM could address these gaps.
Conducting an audit of your existing tools is a powerful way to highlight inefficiencies, missed opportunities, and potential risks.
Map out your current processes and identify where bottlenecks, manual interventions, or data silos exist. Quantify the time and resources spent on these inefficiencies and translate them into financial terms. How much time could you save if you didn’t have to deal with those things? What could you do with that time?
Present these findings to your board alongside a detailed comparison of how a new CRM could streamline operations, enhance donor engagement, and provide a foundation for future growth.
Breaking free from the “good enough” mindset is about more than just upgrading technology—it’s about positioning your nonprofit for success. By embracing a new CRM, you’re not just fixing what’s broken; you’re building a stronger, more efficient, and more effective organization.
Year-End Giving Resources!
As you plan out your year-end giving campaign, Neon One’s Year-End Resource Center has all the templates, guides, checklists, and articles your need to craft messages that’ll send you into next year on a high note.
Objection #3: “We don’t need all those bells and whistles.”
When you propose a new CRM, board members may object by saying that they prefer a simpler, cheaper solution. While this perspective is based on a desire to be fiscally responsible, it’s crucial to challenge this line of thinking by focusing on the long-term needs and growth of the organization.
Find a CRM that Can Scale With Your Nonprofit
Opting for a CRM that only meets your current needs might seem like a practical decision in the short term, but it can lead to significant challenges down the road.
A basic CRM might be sufficient for managing your current donor database, but what happens when your fundraising efforts expand, your donor base grows, or you need to implement more sophisticated campaigns?
As your nonprofit grows, so too will the complexity of your operations. A CRM that can scale with your organization— providing the flexibility to add new features, integrate with other tools, and expand your data management capabilities as needed—will not only support this growth but also enable it.
On the other hand, a system that lacks advanced features such as donor segmentation, automated workflows, and detailed reporting can quickly become a bottleneck, forcing your organization to either upgrade prematurely or struggle with inefficiencies.
While it might be tempting to save money by choosing a simpler, cheaper CRM, it’s important to consider the hidden costs of underinvestment. A basic CRM might save you money upfront, but the long-term costs can far outweigh those initial savings.
A less capable system can lead to inefficiencies, missed opportunities, and even donor attrition if it fails to support your nonprofit’s growth and evolving needs.
Respond by Presenting a Strategic Vision
To help your board understand the importance of investing in more than just the basics, it’s essential to present a strategic vision for how a more advanced CRM will support the organization’s growth and impact.
Create a detailed list of key CRM features that are essential for growing nonprofits, such as advanced reporting, donor segmentation, automation, and integration capabilities.
Present this list to the board along with a comparison of how a basic CRM would limit your organization’s potential versus how a more advanced system would enable long-term success.
Choosing a CRM is not just about meeting today’s needs—it’s about preparing your nonprofit for the challenges and opportunities of tomorrow. By investing in a system that goes beyond the basics, you’re equipping your organization with the tools it needs to grow, adapt, and thrive.
Objection #4: “Implementation will be too disruptive.”
When it comes to adopting new software, particularly a CRM, the fear that transitioning to a new system will disrupt daily operations, burden staff with additional work, or lead to extended periods of downtime can make boards hesitant to greenlight the change.
These concerns are valid, but they can be effectively managed with the right approach and planning.
Respond with a Detailed Implementation Plan
To effectively counteract implementation anxiety, it’s crucial to present your board with a clear, detailed implementation plan. This plan should outline:
- Timeline: A step-by-step timeline that shows each phase of the implementation process, from initial planning to full system adoption.
- Responsibilities: Clear delineation of roles and responsibilities, both within your organization and on the CRM provider’s side. This helps ensure accountability and transparency throughout the process.
- Training Schedule: A detailed training schedule that outlines when and how staff will be trained, with considerations for their current workload and responsibilities.
- Support Resources: A list of the support resources available to your team, including contacts for the CRM provider’s support team, links to training materials, and a plan for accessing help during and after the transition.
Share this implementation plan with your board, along with a checklist of key milestones. Regular updates during the implementation process can help maintain confidence and keep everyone aligned on progress.
Overcoming implementation anxiety is about building confidence—in the plan, in the process, and in the people involved. By addressing the board’s concerns head-on and outlining a clear, supportive process, you can demonstrate that adopting a new CRM is not only feasible but a major leap forward for your organization.
Here’s How Neon CRM Handles Implementation
It’s crucial to reassure your board that modern CRM implementations are designed to be as smooth and non-disruptive as possible. Many CRM providers understand the challenges nonprofits face and have developed robust implementation processes to address these very concerns.
We speak from experience! At Neon One, we have actually made the decision to include required implementation and data migration packages as a part of our onboarding—because we found that clients who completed these processes were twice as likely to succeed as those who didn’t.
The implementation process varies according to your nonprofit’s specific needs, but it generally includes a two-week orientation stage followed by two weeks of planning alongside your Implementation Consultant and, finally, an 8-week training and configuration stage that mixes self-directed courses in Neon One Academy with live training sessions.
Our data migration packages, meanwhile, run the gamut from a simple guided self-import to a standard, semi-customized migration to fully custom scripts that migrate all of your nonprofit’s data.
If that all sounds like a lot, you’re not wrong. But it’s worth it, we promise! A strong, carefully guided implementation process yields huge benefits down the line—all with minimal disruptions to your nonprofit’s daily operations. To learn more about our implementation and data migration packages, check out this sheet.
Objection #5: “This could put our data at risk.”
In today’s digital age, data security isn’t a luxury—it’s a necessity. Nonprofit boards are acutely aware of their responsibility to safeguard the organization’s financial health, and a significant part of that responsibility involves protecting donor data.
With the increasing frequency of data breaches and cyber threats, security concerns are valid and should be a top priority when considering any new software, especially a CRM that handles sensitive information.
The Key Security Features of Modern CRMS
Data security isn’t just about preventing unauthorized access to your data; it’s about protecting the very trust that donors place in your organization. Donors expect their personal and financial information to be handled with the utmost care.
A single breach can lead to severe consequences, including financial losses, legal liabilities, and a damaged reputation that could take years to rebuild.
Fortunately, modern CRMs like Neon CRM are designed with these challenges in mind. They come equipped with robust security features that not only protect your data but also ensure compliance with industry standards such as the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS). These features are built into the CRM’s architecture, providing multiple layers of protection to safeguard your organization’s data.
Some of these features include:
- Encryption: With data encryption, all sensitive information—including things like donor credit card numbers and personal details—is encrypted both in transit and at rest. Even if unauthorized individuals were to gain access to the data, they wouldn’t be able to read it without the appropriate decryption keys.
- Access Controls: Another critical feature is role-based access control (RBAC), which allows you to restrict access to sensitive data based on a user’s role within the organization. RBAC ensures that employees can only access the information necessary for their job, reducing the risk of internal data breaches.
- Regular Security Audits: Modern CRMs also undergo regular security audits and vulnerability assessments conducted by independent third parties. These audits help identify potential weaknesses in the system and ensure that the CRM provider is continuously improving their security measures.
- Two-Factor Authentication (2FA): Two-factor authentication is another essential security feature that adds an extra layer of protection. By requiring users to provide two forms of identification before accessing the CRM—such as a password and a one-time code sent to their phone—2FA significantly reduces the likelihood of unauthorized access.
Beyond the immediate benefits of protecting your nonprofit from data breaches and regulatory penalties, thorough CRM security features also play a crucial role in building and maintaining donor trust.
Trust is the foundation of any successful fundraising effort. When donors are confident that their information is secure, they’re more likely to continue supporting your organization. Over time, a reputation for strong data security can become a significant asset for your nonprofit.
Respond By Highlighting the System’s Security Features
To effectively address your board’s concerns about security, it’s important to present a clear, comprehensive overview of the CRM’s security features and how they protect the organization.
This involves more than just listing features; it requires demonstrating how these features align with the board’s responsibility to safeguard the nonprofit’s fiscal well-being.
Prepare a detailed security checklist that outlines how the new CRM meets or exceeds all necessary compliance requirements. This checklist should include key features such as encryption, role-based access controls, two-factor authentication, and regular security audits.
Additionally, information on CRM compliance with relevant data protection regulations like PCI DSS should be included. If available, include summaries of recent security audit reports conducted by the CRM provider.
Investing in a CRM with robust security features is not just about protecting your nonprofit from immediate threats—it’s about securing the long-term trust and confidence of your donors.
By prioritizing data security and ensuring compliance with industry standards, your nonprofit can safeguard its reputation, avoid costly breaches, and create a secure environment that fosters donor loyalty.
Use This Checklist to Build Your Presentation
Overcoming board objections to purchasing a new CRM requires a strategic approach. By addressing concerns about cost, implementation, and security while highlighting the long-term benefits and ROI, you can make a compelling case for why investing in a new CRM is not just a good idea—it’s essential for the growth and sustainability of your nonprofit.
If you need some help in getting your presentation together, you’re in luck! We’ve created a handy checklist that incorporates all the elements that a persuasive board presentation on purchasing a new piece of nonprofit technology should include!
This checklist is totally free. To download it now, just follow the link below!
6 Steps to Sell Your Board on Nonprofit Technology
If you want to invest in new nonprofit technology and are looking to gain board approval before you do, this is for you. Good luck—you’ve got this!
Join the discussion in our Slack channel on connected fundraising
