For charities and nonprofits across North America, finding the right donor management software could mean the difference between closing in the next three years and thriving for the next 30.
With the right solution in hand, your charity can use better data to make more informed decisions that will increase engagement and boost fundraising. Without the right solution, you’ll be left guessing as to what works and what doesn’t—a situation that never leads anywhere good.
But, while it’s true that charities in Canada and the U.S. have a lot in common when it comes to making sound strategic decisions, it’s also true that, for Canadian charities, the list of donor management software options is going to look a little different than the list of options available to their nonprofit cousins in the U.S.
That’s why, in this guide, we’ll explore the top five donor management software solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of Canadian charities. But before we get into that, let’s talk about the key features your nonprofit should be looking for in a new system.
Your Donor Management Features Checklist
Before you can really start shopping for a new donor management system, you need to have a list of what features you’re looking for. Here’s a handy checklist of important donor management capabilities that you can use to guide your search for a new solution.
Donor Database & CRM Capabilities
Managing donor information efficiently sits at the heart of a well-run donor management program.
That’s why the foundation of your donor management software should be a donor database with a robust set of tools for collecting, storing, and analyzing info on your constituents.
Customizable fields and robust search capabilities are essential, as they enable you to tailor the database to meet your nonprofit’s unique needs and quickly retrieve specific donor data.
Donation Tracking & Management
Top-notch donor management software should have the ability to track donations, pledges, and recurring gifts seamlessly.
It should provide a comprehensive donation history for each donor, allowing you to see past contributions, payment methods, and any specific donor preferences.
Look for software that integrates effortlessly with your fundraising campaigns, enabling you to link donations directly to specific events or appeals.
Donation Forms
Beyond the ability to track your donations, your donor management system should come equipped with features to collect those donations.
A donation form builder that lets you quickly spin up fully customized donation pages will help you target specific donor groups and ensure that they make it all the way through the process.
If you’d like to know a little bit more about creating donation pages, here’s a handy guide we’ve created on just that subject:
Communication Tools
Look for software that integrates effortlessly with your fundraising campaigns, enabling you to link donations directly to specific events or appeals.
Effective communication with your supporters is crucial for maintaining strong relationships and building a base of committed, long-time givers.
Integrated email marketing features allow you to send personalized messages, newsletters, and fundraising appeals directly from the software.
Additionally, text messaging and social media capabilities can help expand your outreach efforts. While email is the most important feature your CRM should include, keep an eye out for these, too.
Event & Volunteer Management
Events are a tried and true way for charities to raise money while engaging their supporters and building a sense of community.
Meanwhile, the vast majority of charities rely on the efforts of their dedicated volunteers to live out their missions.
That’s why incorporating event and volunteer management features is such a plus for donor management platforms.
See what a prospective solution can provide in terms of event and volunteer management—and at what price point.
Reporting & Analytics
Advanced reporting capabilities that’s built right into your database will help your charity’s staff to analyze donor behavior, campaign performance, and overall fundraising success.
The software should offer customizable reports and visual dashboards that provide insights into key metrics such as donation amounts, donor retention rates, and campaign effectiveness.
These tools allow you to make data-driven decisions and optimize your fundraising strategies.
To streamline operations and ensure data consistency across your organization, the software should be compatible with other tools you use, like accounting software, email marketing platforms, and event management systems.
Integrations
To streamline operations and ensure data consistency across your organization, the software should be compatible with other tools you use, such as accounting software, email marketing platforms, and event management systems.
Seamless integration with these tools helps avoid data silos and reduces the need for manual data entry, thereby enhancing efficiency and accuracy.
Compliance
For Canadian nonprofits, compliance with Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) regulations is paramount.
The donor management software should support CRA compliance by providing features that facilitate tax receipting and reporting.
This includes the ability to issue tax receipts in the correct format, maintain accurate records for auditing purposes, and generate reports that meet CRA requirements.
5 Top Donor Management Solutions: Reviewed (2024)
Not to sound cryptic, but the best donor management software solution for your charity is going to be …. The software solution that works best for your charity.
In other words: There’s no right answer when it comes to selecting a donor management platform for your organization. It’s about which solution best fulfills your charity’s needs.
In this section, we’ll help you find that ideal fit by taking an in-depth look at five leading donor management solutions that are well-suited for Canadian nonprofits.
By examining our product, Neon CRM, alongside DonorPerfect, Bloomerang, Keela, and Sumac, we hope to help you identify the best software to meet your charity’s specific needs.
All the customer reviews cited here are based on real customer reviews of these solutions on G2, Capterra, and Software Advice.
1. Neon CRM
That’s us! Neon CRM is a comprehensive donor management software designed specifically for charities and charities. With its comprehensive features and scalable pricing, Neon CRM is well-suited for small to mid-sized organizations aiming to streamline their operations, grow their donor base, and improve engagement efforts.
Features
Neon CRM’s key features include the following:
- Donor Database: The software includes customizable fields, which allow organizations to track donor information and relationships effectively.
- Fundraising Tools: Organizations can build unlimited, fully customized donation forms, incorporating best practices to optimize their fundraising efforts.
- Communications: The system features an easy-to-use email builder, along with text-to-communicate capabilities for engaging with donors and volunteers.
- Membership: Neon CRM offers a variety of membership features, including custom forms, portals, renewals, directories, and more, to manage memberships efficiently.
- Event Management: The software provides event management tools for registration, ticketing, and attendee tracking, with a special emphasis on managing classes.
- Volunteer Management: There are features available for managing volunteer activities and schedules and streamlining volunteer coordination.
- Payments: Neon Pay is Neon One’s built-in payment processor, which is available for use in Canada and ensures smooth financial transactions.
- Automated Workflows: The system helps you automate repetitive tasks, saving you time and reducing errors in your daily operations.
- Reporting and Analytics: Neon CRM includes more than 40 pre-built reports and customizable dashboards, allowing organizations to track and analyze performance.
- Compliance: The software ensures the secure handling of credit card information with built-in compliance features, including compliance with the CRA.
- Integrations: Neon CRM offers custom integrations with over 50 partner organizations, enhancing its functionality and connectivity.
- Quickbooks: Neon CRM is an Intuit QuickBooks Solution Provider, which means we have a truly seamless integration with Quickbooks Online.
- Neon Websites: The software seamlessly integrates with Neon Websites, enabling a powerful digital marketing operation based on real-time data.
Pros & Cons
Here are some of the strengths and weaknesses of Neon CRM, as reported by our customers.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Event & Email Features: Users frequently highlight the excellent integration of event management and email marketing tools, which greatly simplifies organizing and promoting events. Seamless Integrations: The platform integrates well with other essential tools like QuickBooks, MailChimp, and Eventbrite, which helps streamline operations and maintain data consistency across platforms. User-Friendly Interface: Many users find Neon CRM exceptionally easy to navigate and use, especially compared to other CRM platforms. The dashboard is designed to be intuitive and accessible even for those who are not tech-savvy. Affordability: Neon CRM is noted for being more affordable than similar products, offering a great balance of features and cost-effectiveness. Robust Reporting & Analytics: Users value the comprehensive reporting capabilities, which include over 40 pre-built reports and customizable dashboards. This helps organizations track donor behavior, campaign performance, and overall fundraising success. | Initial Setup Learning Curve: The system’s extensive features can result in a learning curve, especially during the initial setup, many users find that the effort is well worth it for the powerful functionality provided. Customization Complexity: Customizing the system to fit specific organizational needs can be complex and time-consuming, but the end result is a highly tailored and effective CRM solution. Some Added Costs for Advanced Features: While Neon CRM is generally affordable, some users note that the costs can become higher for advanced features like event and volunteer management, which are not included in the lowest-cost tier (Essentials). Feature Limitations: Some users have pointed out limitations in the email and event management functionalities. However, ongoing updates and improvements continue to address these issues, allowing charities to avoid adding additional email and event platforms to their tech stack. |
Pricing
Neon CRM offers three pricing tiers, each designed to meet different needs and budgets. The pricing is based on an organization’s revenue instead of its number of records, which means you only pay more as you raise more:
- Essentials: Starting at $99/mo, this package includes core tools for donor management, basic reporting, and one active workflow.
- Impact: Starting at $199/mo, this package adds features like QuickBooks integration, event and volunteer management, 15 active workflows, and an open API.
- Empower: Starting at $399/mo, this package includes all features from the Impact package, plus live chat and phone support, radius search, and unlimited active workflows.
Would you like to learn more about Neon CRM? Join one of our group demos! These regularly scheduled 30-minute sessions will provide you with an overview of everything the system can do. We look forward to seeing you there!
2. DonorPerfect
DonorPerfect is a donor management solution with localized services that can help Canadian charities streamline their fundraising efforts, enhance donor relationships, and manage data efficiently.
Features
DonorPerfect’s platform includes the following key features:
- Centralized Database: DonorPerfect has a centralized database that securely stores all donor information.
- Enhanced Donor Relationships: The software supports personalized communication through automated emails and customizable templates.
- Efficient Fundraising: DonorPerfect supports a wide range of fundraising activities, including online donations, event management, and peer-to-peer fundraising.
- Comprehensive Reporting: The software allows charities to generate detailed reports and analytics, including unlimited custom reports and scheduled reports delivered to your inbox.
- Customization and Flexibility: DonorPerfect is highly customizable, allowing charities to tailor data entry screens and record layouts to suit their specific needs.
- Integration Capabilities: The software integrates with many other essential tools and platforms, including Constant Contact, DonorSearch, and GiveCloud.
- Security and Data Management: DonorPerfect has strict security protocols to protect donor data. Data hosting within Canada provides additional security and compliance with local regulations.
- Mobile Access: The DonorPerfect mobile app allows charities to manage donor interactions and track fundraising activities on the go.
- Localized Support: DonorPerfect offers bilingual (English and French) support and training, ensuring effective communication and assistance for Canadian charities.
- Compliance: The software is equipped to handle CRA tax receipting, ensuring that all donation receipts meet Canadian Revenue Agency standards.
- No Long-Term Contracts: Flexible terms with no long-term contract commitments can make DonorPerfect an attractive option for charities that are looking to adjust their use of the software as needed.
User Reviews
According to our analysis of reviews from real customers, DonorPerfect has the following overall strengths and weaknesses:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| User-Friendly Interface: Many users highlight the intuitive and easy-to-navigate interface. The dashboard is designed to display information in an easy-to-read format, making it accessible even for those who are not tech-savvy. Customer Support: DonorPerfect is praised for its responsive and helpful customer support team. Users find the support staff knowledgeable and quick to resolve issues. Continuous Improvement: The software is frequently updated with new features and improvements, ensuring it remains relevant and up-to-date with the latest trends in charity management. | Reporting Difficulties: Some users find it challenging to run reports and believe that the reporting features could be more intuitive and user-friendly. Cost of Upgrades: There are concerns about the cost of upgrade features, with users noting that it can be difficult to distinguish between what is included in the base package and what requires additional payment. Limited Scope: A few reviews mention that DonorPerfect’s overall scope is somewhat limited and does not cover certain advanced functionalities beyond basic data storage and donor management. |
Pricing
DonorPerfect offers a range of pricing plans to accommodate charities of different sizes and needs. Pricing starts at $99/mo and is typically based on the number of donor records and additional features required. Contact DonorPerfect directly for more specific information.
3. Bloomerang
Bloomerang is a charity CRM platform designed to help charities deliver a better giving experience. Their donor management software provides essential tools for charity organizations to manage their donor relationships, fundraising efforts, and overall operations more efficiently.
Features
Here are some of Bloomerang’s core features and capabilities:
- Centralized Donor Database: Bloomerang’s donor database allows charities to store and manage all donor information in one place.
- Online Giving: The software offers unlimited donation pages and forms, as well as peer-to-peer and crowdfunding tools.
- Volunteer Management: Bloomerang simplifies volunteer management by consolidating volunteer data with donor and member information.
- Membership Management: The platform includes membership management tools that allow charities to attract, retain, and engage members effectively.
- Marketing & Engagement: Bloomerang offers marketing and engagement tools, including built-in email marketing, social media integration, and customizable communication templates.
- Reporting & Analytics: The software provides smart reporting features that allow charities to create detailed reports using a filter-based system.
- Mobile Access: Bloomerang’s mobile app allows charities to manage donor interactions and track fundraising activities on the go.
Pros & Cons
According to customer reviews, Bloomerang’s solution has the following overall strengths and weaknesses:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| User-Friendly Interface: Many users praise Bloomerang for its intuitive and easy-to-navigate interface. It is designed to be accessible even for those who are not particularly tech-savvy. Comprehensive Functionality: Bloomerang offers a wide range of features, and users appreciate the all-in-one nature of the platform. It helps them streamline their operations and reduce the need for multiple tools. Efficient Donor Management: Users report that Bloomerang has significantly improved their ability to manage donor relationships. They particularly appreciate features like the integrated email application, which tracks donor interactions, and the dashboard, which displays donor retention rates and campaign progress. | Limited Customization: Some users feel that Bloomerang could offer more customization options, particularly in the areas of reporting and email formatting. Email and Reporting Tools: Several reviews point out that Bloomerang’s email formatting options are somewhat limited and that the reporting tools can be challenging to navigate initially. Data Management Issues: A few users have noted difficulties with certain aspects of data management, such as merging donor records and handling large databases. Inconsistencies between data input filters and reporting filters, which can complicate data management tasks, are also mentioned. Learning Curve: New users may experience a learning curve as they become familiar with Bloomerang’s features and capabilities. |
Pricing
Bloomerang’s pricing starts at $125/mo, with add-on modules available at varying price points. Fundraising is $40/mo, Volunteer Management is $119/mo, and Membership Management is $25/mo. You can learn more on Bloomerang’s website.
4. Keela
Keela is a donor management solution native to Canada designed to help charities streamline their operations, manage donor relationships, and boost fundraising efforts. Keela was recently acquired by the accounting software solution Aplos, which means that their future outlook is currently a bit cloudy.
Features
Keela’s key features include:
- Centralized Donor Database: Keela provides a centralized location for storing all donor data, making it easy to manage and access information.
- Fundraising: Keela supports various fundraising activities, including online donations, peer-to-peer fundraising, and event management.
- Predictive Analytics: Keela’s data analytics tools offer real-time insights and predictions about donor behavior.
- Personalized Communication: The software enables organizations to segment their donor base and create personalized communication strategies.
- Automated Workflows: The platform offers automation features that streamline repetitive tasks, such as sending acknowledgment emails and setting up donor journeys.
- Reporting: Keela provides robust reporting and analytics capabilities, allowing charities to generate detailed reports on donor behavior, campaign performance, and overall fundraising success.
- Volunteer Management: Keela offers tools for managing volunteers, including tracking volunteer hours, managing member renewals, and coordinating volunteer activities.
Pros & Cons
According to reviews from their customers, Keela’s platform has the following pluses and minuses.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| User-Friendly Interface: Many users praise Keela for its intuitive and easy-to-use interface. The platform’s design is accessible to users of all tech skill levels, making it easier for charity staff to manage donor data and fundraising activities. Excellent Customer Support: Keela is highly regarded for its responsive and helpful customer support team. Users appreciate the prompt assistance and personalized support they receive, enhancing their overall experience with the software. Effective Donor Management: Due to Keela’s robust features, users report significant improvements in managing donor relationships. The predictive analytics, personalized communication tools, and automated workflows are particularly valued for their impact on donor engagement and retention. | Integration Challenges: Some users have experienced difficulties integrating Keela with other tools and platforms. For example, there have been struggles with integrating MailChimp, leading to some frustration. Email & Campaign Management: Setting up e-blast letters and campaigns can be challenging for some users. The difficulty in getting quick answers and the complexity of setting up campaigns have been noted as areas needing improvement. Learning Curve: Some users note that there is a learning curve associated with Keela, particularly when getting started. While the platform is user-friendly, it can take time to fully understand and utilize all its features and capabilities. Customization Options: A few reviews mention that Keela could offer more customization options, especially in reporting and form creation. |
Pricing
Keela offers flexible pricing plans to accommodate charities of different sizes and needs. Pricing is based on the number of contacts and ranges from $125/mo to $350/mo (with discounts for charities who bill annually instead of monthly). Charities with more than 10,000 contacts can contact them directly for a customized quote.
5. Sumac by Societ
Sumac is a donor management platform from Societ that’s designed to help charities streamline their operations, manage donor relationships, and enhance fundraising efforts. With a strong focus on user-friendly features and customizable options, Sumac aims to meet the diverse needs of charity organizations.
Features
Here are some of Sumac’s core features:
- Centralized Donor Database: Sumac offers a robust centralized database that securely stores all donor information.
- Customizable Forms: The software allows charities to create and customize forms for different programs, making it easier to collect and manage specific data.
- Integrated Fundraising Tools: Sumac supports a wide range of fundraising activities, including online donations, event management, and peer-to-peer fundraising.
- Comprehensive Reporting: The software provides detailed reporting and analytics features that help charities understand donor behavior and measure campaign success.
- Membership & Volunteer Management: Sumac offers tools to manage membership and volunteer programs, allowing charities to track engagement, manage renewals, and coordinate volunteer activities efficiently.
- Email Marketing: The platform includes email marketing capabilities that enable charities to create and send targeted email campaigns.
User Reviews
Our analysis of Sumac’s customer reviews found the following strengths and weaknesses.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Value for Money: Sumac is considered to offer good value for money, providing a comprehensive set of features at a competitive price point. Users appreciate the flexibility and functionality that the software offers. Ease of Use: Many users find Sumac to be user-friendly and intuitive once they become familiar with the program. They highly value the ability to customize forms and reports to meet specific needs. Customer Support: Users consistently praise Sumac for its excellent customer support. The support team is noted for being responsive, patient, and helpful in resolving issues. | Data Export & Management: Some users have reported challenges with data export and management. Specifically, there are mentions of difficulties in exporting data to Excel and the inability to delete mistakes easily. Integration Glitches: A few reviews highlight problems with integrating website donations with the software. Users have experienced glitches that make it difficult to track online donations seamlessly. Learning Curve: New users may experience a learning curve as they get accustomed to Sumac’s comprehensive features. While the software is user-friendly, it can take some time to fully understand and utilize all its functionalities effectively. |
Pricing
Sumac offers a flexible pricing structure, with pricing based on the specific modules and features selected.
The base package starts at $49/mo and includes essential CRM features plus email, with a 1,000-record capacity. On top of that base package, charities can add specialized modules for functions such as:
- Membership Management
- Volunteer Management
- Event Management
- Grant Management
- Case Management
For a detailed pricing quote and to learn more about the available modules, you can contact Sumac directly or visit their website.
Check Out Our Nonprofit CRM Buyer’s Guide
Choosing the right donor management software is a crucial decision for your charity. Hopefully, the information we’ve included in this post will help your charity find the right solution for your needs, your capabilities, and (let’s not forget) your budget.
If you’d like some additional assistance, we highly recommend downloading our comprehensive Buyer’s Guide to Choosing a Nonprofit CRM. This guide provides in-depth insights, practical checklists, and expert advice to ensure you select a CRM that aligns perfectly with your goals.
Download your copy today and take the first step towards transforming your donor management strategy.
Join the discussion in our Slack channel on connected fundraising
