Skip to Main Content

11 Ways Your Nonprofit Can Create Loyal Donors

14 min read
April 17, 2024
Neon One Staff
4 dark-haired women sitting on the beach with their arms around one another, facing away from the camera.

For any nonprofit to succeed in the long term, it needs a donor base that’s committed to the long term, too. Loyal donors won’t just provide your organization with financial stability, they’ll also be passionate champions for your cause.

Creating a base of loyal, ride-or-die donors isn’t easy—one might go so far as to say that it’s “quite difficult”—but the results are worth it. In this post, we’ll talk about 11 different things you can do to create loyal donors and secure your organization’s future.

Why Are Loyal Donors So Important? 

Loyal donors are important because they will form the foundation of pretty much anything your nonprofit wants to do.

These devoted supporters provide a reliable stream of funds that let you confidently pursue your mission, safe in knowing that the funds will be there when you need them. But they do more than that; they also become ambassadors for your cause, spreading the word about your nonprofit and bringing in new supporters.

And, of course, when it comes to stretching your nonprofit’s dollar, never forget that retaining existing donors is more cost-effective than acquiring new ones. With every new donation an existing supporter makes, their value to your nonprofit increases. 

In fact, recurring donors who make regular, scheduled gifts to their favorite organizations are some of the most loyal—and most valuable—supporters you can find. You can read all about the rising importance of recurring donations by downloading The Recurring Giving Report: Data-Backed Insights for Sustainable Generosity

How Donor Management Software Can Help

To build a base of loyal donors, it’s crucial to understand their motivations and connect with them on a deeper level. In order to do that, you need three things: a way to collect data, a way to store that data, and a way to analyze that data.

In other words, you’ll need some kind of donor management software. These software solutions are designed specifically to centralize donor information in a single database, track interactions, and analyze giving patterns, providing you with a comprehensive view of each supporter.

But the best donor management software systems don’t only help you better understand your donors, they also include tools like donor segmentation, task automation, and form builders that help you cut down on busy work and devote more time to building relationships. 

Throughout this article, you’ll see mentions of our own donor management solution, Neon CRM. If this article piques your interest and you want to learn more, you can sign up for one of our regularly scheduled Neon CRM group demos to get a closer look.

1. Segment Your Donor Communications 

Building loyalty to your nonprofit begins with sending donors the right kinds of messages. So what is the right kind of message? Well, it depends on the donor! Different types of donors want to hear about different kinds of things. 

This is where donor segmentation comes in. By separating donors into different groups (or “segments” based on factors like giving history, demographics, interests, and engagement levels, you can craft messages that resonate with each group.

This targeted approach ensures that your communication will always be relevant and impactful, increasing the likelihood that your donors will stick around. For fundraising appeals, you can take this strategy a step further by creating personalized donation pages, too. 

Any contact management tool your nonprofit uses to send emails and other communications will have segmentation capabilities. By using a donor management system like Neon CRM that comes with email tools built in, you’ll be able to identify and build these segments far faster.

An image of a computer with a the Neon CRM Email Builder tour on the screen. Click on the image to take the tour!
An image of a computer with a the Neon CRM Email Builder tour on the screen. Click on the image to take the tour!

2. Send Personalized Impact Reports

One thing that all donor segments have in common: They want to know that their gifts are making a difference. That’s why personalized impact reports that highlight (and celebrate) the tangible results of an individual donor’s support can inspire real loyalty. 

Like any impact report, these missives should include specific examples, stories, and data that directly relate to their contributions, providing a clear and compelling account of their impact.

This is an area where donor segmentation and the right set of donor management tools can be a true time-saver:

  • Step 1: You create donor segments that correspond to different gift size ranges
  • Step 2: You craft impact updates tailored for each segment 
  • Step 3: You set up automated workflows that automatically send these update emails
  • Step 4: You use personalization tokens to ensure that each donor’s name and gift size are accurate
  • Step 5: There is no Step 5. You’re done!
A screenshot of an email composed in Neon CRM with a personalization token in the salutation that will pull the constituent's first name from the nonprofit's database and add it to the email.
Personalization tokens are pieces of code that pull information from your database and let you send one email to multiple recipients while still addressing each person by name.

3. Create a Donor Appreciation Strategy

Building a long-term relationship with donors is a lot like building a long-term relationship with a romantic partner: You’ve got to find ways to regularly show them just how much you appreciate them. 

So how can you do that? There are plenty of ways! 

Let’s start with the most obvious one: Right after a gift is made, you should be sending your donors a heartfelt thank-you message. Email is great for these, but you should also find ways to include the occasional handwritten note or phone call, as those are the kinds of touches that make a lasting impression. 

Taking things a step further, publicly recognizing your donors by featuring them in a newsletter or shouting them out on social media can enhance their sense of pride and belonging. If you print any kind of written impact reports, make sure they mention all your donors by name.

Celebrating donor milestones, such as anniversaries of their first donation or reaching certain giving levels, can also add a special touch to your appreciation efforts. These gestures show that you not only remember their contributions but also cherish their ongoing support.

4. Throw Events Celebrating Your Donors

All three of the strategies we’ve discussed so far have focused on digital interactions, but throwing some IRL donor appreciation events is another great way to celebrate your supporters and foster feelings of loyalty.

These events can range from intimate small-group gatherings to larger celebrations, but they should always focus on helping donors connect with each other and with your organization’s leadership,

Creating memorable experiences where donors can witness the impact of their contributions firsthand can be particularly effective, while offering exclusive insights or previews of upcoming projects can create a sense of exclusivity and importance.

What kind of events your nonprofit throws will depend on the kinds of events your donors want to attend! Tailoring events to your donors’ interests, whether they’re educational workshops, volunteer activities, or social gatherings, will help ensure their success. 

Event management software can help during every step of the event planning process, from tickets and registrations to seating charts, communications, check-ins, and more. Did we mention that Neon CRM has an awesome array of event management capabilities? Well, it does!

Check out this article for more information:

5. Hold Personal Donor Meetings

When we’ve talked about all the ways that donor management software can help free up time to build relationships with donors, taking the time to hold one-on-one meetings is precisely the kind of thing you should be doing.

These personal interactions will provide an opportunity to discuss your donor’s motivations, share updates on your nonprofit’s achievements, and outline future plans. By taking the time to understand a donor’s interests and concerns, you will foster a deeper connection with them and a sense of partnership.

Follow-up after these meetings is crucial. Sending a personalized thank-you note or a summary of the discussion shows that you value their time and input. Regular check-ins and updates keep the lines of communication open and maintain the relationship’s momentum.

By incorporating feedback from these meetings into your strategies, you’ll strengthen your donors’ commitment to your cause. Your donor management software can also continue to help in this area by tracking meeting notes, scheduling follow-ups, and recording donor preferences. 

6. Ask Your Donors for Feedback

How do you find out what your donors like? You ask them!

But the benefits of actively seeking feedback go deeper than that. By inviting donors to share their thoughts and experiences, you demonstrate that their opinions are valued and that their input plays a crucial role in shaping your nonprofit’s direction.

Donor surveys can be used to gauge donor satisfaction, understand their preferences, and identify areas for improvement. Tailoring your communication and engagement strategies based on this feedback ensures that you are meeting donors’ expectations and addressing their needs.

Providing your donors with opportunities for open dialogue—like feedback forms on your website or interactive Q&A sessions during events—fosters transparency and trust. Listening to and acting on donor feedback shows a commitment to continuous improvement and donor-centricity.

Donor management software will help you gather all this donor feedback. You can use the system to send out your donor surveys, publish your feedback forms, track your responses, and more.

7. Offer Volunteer Opportunities

Offering volunteer opportunities allows your donors to engage with your nonprofit’s work on a deeper level. By participating in hands-on activities, donors will gain a better understanding of your mission and the impact of their contributions.

Tailoring volunteer opportunities to match donors’ skills and interests will enhance their experience and their sense of fulfillment. Acknowledging their efforts and highlighting the difference they’ve made reinforces their importance to your organization.

Donor management software that comes with volunteer management capabilities (like Neon CRM does) can facilitate the coordination of volunteer activities, track participation, and gather feedback, ensuring an organized and rewarding volunteer program.

Done successfully, volunteering will create a feedback loop where volunteers can share their experiences and suggestions, fostering a sense of collaboration and continuous improvement.

A screenshot of a volunteer form created in Neon CRM
With Neon CRM’s volunteer forms, new sign-ups are immediately updated in your system.

8. Use Data to Send Fewer, Better Appeals

The thing about fundraising is that you have to balance staying front of mind for people while trying not to blitz them with so many communications that they get annoyed and check out. 

If you’re trying to create loyal donors, walking this line is key—and it’s a spot where donor data can help big time. 

By analyzing donor data, your nonprofit can uncover patterns and preferences. You can figure out what kinds of messages resonate with which segments of your donor base. Dig deeper, and you can figure out what channels are the best way to reach them or even what times of day are best for them.

Data analytics can also help develop a major donor pipeline and predict giving trends, enabling you to allocate resources more effectively. By focusing on high-potential areas, you can maximize your fundraising today while building a strong foundation of loyal donors for tomorrow. 

Neon CRM recently added a brand new feature to our donor profiles called the Generosity Indicator. It’s a series of scores that give you a more holistic view of all the ways people give their support and help you find new opportunities in your database.

9. Streamline Your Donation Process

Creating a simple, user-friendly donation process might not be the reason people keep coming back—but a truly annoying donation process will definitely encourage them to stop supporting you. 

Removing barriers to donating means creating a great donation form. Luckily, there are lots of industry-standard donation page best practices that you can bring to bear on your organization’s form. Here are a few of the top ones:

  • Use a Multi-Step Form: A donation form that breaks the process down into three separate pages will make filling out those fields seem more manageable and likely increase your donation form’s conversion rates.
  • Include Suggested Donation Amounts: Not only will including suggested donation amounts help save your donors from a minor bout of decision fatigue, but you might be able to subtly encourage them to give more.
  • Add Security Indicators: Something as small as a little padlock icon on your donation form will indicate to donors that their sensitive payment information is safe with your nonprofit, which will encourage them to keep giving. 

When you’re choosing a donor management software system, pay close attention to its donation forms and make sure that they are going to create a pleasant donation experience for your supporters. If the forms aren’t up to your standards, then it’s time to look elsewhere. 

There are so many more best practices to include and factors to consider when designing your organization’s donation pages. For the full rundown, check out Donation Pages: The Ultimate Guide for Nonprofits.

A screenshot of a Neon CRM's donation form for a nonprofit called Agloe Nature Conservancy. Neon CRM's donation forms come with an easy drag-and-drop builder and tons of best practices built in. Click this image to take a Neon CRM Donation Form Builder Tour.
Neon CRM’s donation forms come with an easy drag-and-drop builder and tons of best practices built in. See them in action!

10. Build a Robust Online Presence 

It’s 2024. If you want to build a thriving, loyal donor base, you’ll need a strong online presence based on an engaging and informative website, active social media channels, and compelling digital content. 

Let’s run through those one by one. 

A well-designed nonprofit website serves as your organization’s online hub, providing a platform for storytelling, showcasing impact, and facilitating donations. Ensuring that your site is user-friendly and mobile-responsive will enhance the user experience and encourage engagement.

Active social media engagement allows you to reach a broader audience and foster a sense of community among your supporters. Platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram offer opportunities to share updates, celebrate successes, and interact with your donors in real time.

Lastly, creating valuable content, such as blog posts, videos, and newsletters, keeps your audience informed and inspired. Regularly updating your online channels with fresh and relevant content demonstrates your nonprofit’s dynamism and commitment to transparency.

Neon Websites is a nonprofit website builder that integrates seamlessly with Neon CRM and gives you all the tools you need to easily build and maintain an awesome site for your nonprofit. To see the tool in action, take a tour!

11. Form a Donor Advisory Group

Forming a donor advisory group is a strategic way to involve key supporters more directly in your nonprofit’s mission and decision-making. This group can provide valuable insights, feedback, and ideas, fostering a sense of ownership and investment in your organization’s success.

Regular meetings and open lines of communication ensure that the advisory group remains engaged and informed. Recognizing their contributions and incorporating their suggestions into your strategies demonstrate the value of their input.

Transparency about the group’s impact and the outcomes of their recommendations further solidifies their commitment to your cause.

Donor management software can support the management of your advisory group by organizing meeting schedules, tracking member interactions, and storing important documents.

Is it time for a CRM? Click this image to explore our side-by-side comparison to see which platform would be best for your organization.
Is it time for a CRM? Click this image to explore our side-by-side comparison to see which platform would be best for your organization.

Download The Recurring Giving Report for More Insights

Creating loyal donors is essential for the long-term success and sustainability of your nonprofit. By implementing the strategies outlined in this guide, you can cultivate a dedicated community of passionate advocates who will help drive your mission forward.

If you want the full picture of how committed supporters can show up for their favorite nonprofits, download The Recurring Giving Report: Data-Backed Insights for Sustainable Generosity. We analyzed data from over 100,000 donors to over 2,000 nonprofits over a 5-year span and found that recurring donors are more important now than ever before.

Think your nonprofit is too small to build a recurring giving program? Think again. Our report includes findings (and expert advice) for small, midsize, and large nonprofits. What are you waiting for? Download the report and start building a base of loyal donors today. 

Join the discussion in our Slack channel on connected fundraising

Looking to become a more connected nonprofit leader?

Join 73,000+ of your peers getting industry news, tips, and resources straight to their inbox.